Criteria sheets
The following sheets represent our own criteria for each category.
Dimension 📐 |
Scores
|
Criteria
|
9
|
The game aims to be the next big thing that revolutionizes a genre or even the entire game industry.
|
7-8
|
A highly ambitious game with extensive content, innovative mechanics, and/or advanced technical features
|
5-6
|
A moderately ambitious game, with well-understood challenges and a safely measured scope.
|
3-4
|
A small game, focused on a specific set of straightforward concepts.
|
1-2
|
An extremely casual and straightforward game, typically featuring a single game mode, basic settings, and a high score system.
|
🦅Flair 🦊Feel 🐝Fuel |
Scores
|
Decimal equivalence
|
Theme
|
Criteria
|
F
|
10
|
FouttaF
|
The ultimate score! F outta F!
|
E
|
9.3
|
Diamond
|
Outstanding! So close to perfection you can smell it.
|
D
|
8.7
|
Platinum
|
Excellent! Better than great, like finding money in an old jacket
|
C
|
8
|
Gold
|
Great! Like getting all the toppings on your pizza.
|
B
|
7.3
|
Silver
|
Very good! Long way to go until perfection, but solid performance.
|
A
|
6.7
|
Bronze
|
Nice! Could have been better though.
|
9
|
6
|
Meh
|
Decent but forgettable, like a movie you only watch once.
|
8
|
5.3
|
Weak Sauce
|
Underwhelming. Like bringing a spoon to a knife fight.
|
7
|
4.7
|
Ehhh...
|
Not terrible, but not great either. Like lukewarm coffee.
|
6
|
4
|
Uh-Oh
|
Not everything is wrong, but it's definitely not right.
|
5
|
3.3
|
Yikes!
|
Poor... It's getting hard to find something to salvage.
|
4
|
2.7
|
Train Wreck
|
At this point, there's no sugar-coating it. Just bad.
|
3
|
2
|
Dumpster Fire
|
A milestone of horribleness. Time to rethink your life choices.
|
2
|
1.3
|
Epic Fail
|
Hard to do worse. Like crashing a bike into a cactus.
|
1
|
0.7
|
The Abyss
|
Almost impossible to do worse. This score needs a hug.
|
0
|
0
|
Rock Bottom
|
Zero. Zilch. Nada. The epitome of failure.
|
/
|
N\A
|
Non applicable
|
Ocasionally, a category won't apply to be rated and will be left blank.
|
Trait Scores Sheets
Story Drive📖 |
Scores
|
Criteria
|
18-20
|
The story IS the game
|
15-17
|
The story has a huge importance, but there's much more to the game
|
10-14
|
The story is there but plays a secondary role
|
5-9
|
There are some narrative elements in the game that provide context
|
0-4
|
There's no narrative and the story is minimal, if any
|
Accessibility🚪 |
Scores
|
Criteria
|
18-20
|
Your grandma could probably play it
|
15-17
|
A few minor barriers but still highly accessible
|
10-14
|
Some significant barriers, tutorials are recommended (if any)
|
5-9
|
Tutorials are essential to even grasp the basics
|
0-4
|
Highly inaccessible, few to none tutorials
|
Depth🤿 |
Scores
|
Criteria
|
18-20
|
A massive universe of concepts and mechanics with infinite depth
|
15-17
|
The amount of mechanics and the depth they entail is remarkable
|
10-14
|
There are at least a few concepts with considerable depth
|
5-9
|
Slightly deep mechanics here and there
|
0-4
|
Straightforward and plain, no depth whatsoever
|
Challenge💀 |
Scores
|
Criteria
|
18-20
|
Extremely difficult, you'll be miserable
|
15-17
|
Remarkably challenging or featuring really tough modes
|
10-14
|
Average challenge
|
5-9
|
Fairly easy, you may have to lean in from time to time.
|
0-4
|
A walk in the park, perhaps literally.
|
Duration⌛ |
Scores
|
Criteria
|
18-20
|
Absurdly long, almost feels unlimited
|
15-17
|
Great amount of hours to be played
|
10-14
|
Average length for a regular single player experience
|
5-9
|
Usually games you can finish in under 6-7 hours.
|
0-4
|
Super short experience, 2-3 hours to complete at most.
|
Freedom🌎 |
Scores
|
Criteria
|
18-20
|
Freedom is the key element of the gameplay
|
15-17
|
Great liberty granted to the player
|
10-14
|
Linear backbone, but there's plenty of freedom on top of it
|
5-9
|
Pretty linear, but there are a few elements that break that linearity
|
0-4
|
The game is a straight line
|
Disclaimer
When reviewing retro games, we strive to rate them as we would have at the time of their release. For instance, while GTA III might seem outdated today and most would prefer GTA V, we evaluate it as the groundbreaking game it was in 2001. Even if it didn't age well.
Although we aim to be objective and impartial, we acknowledge that our reviews are influenced by our own preferences. Please understand that our scores are subjective and just our opinion.